I’m not. My statement was (quite obviously, I think) an illustration of the bizarre logic of interpreting “A is better than B” as “people who have difficulties with A should be gatekept from the subject altogether and not use B either”.
Reading literally engages different parts of your brain that are otherwise dormant.
That’s still not “a lot more cognitive effort” that you claimed, though, and also not proof that it reduces your appreciation of the animation.
And as I mentioned, sometimes I want to watch stuff while high.
Who cares? That’s such a specific use case, nobody is arguing for or against dubbing with regards to how much you can follow it while high.
Sometimes I want to give my eyes a break from using my glasses or reading things in fine detail.
but it is also very common for myself and a lot of other people to be doing other things and having TV on in the background
Writing this after previously arguing dubbing is better because it allows you to follow the animation more attentively is just ridiculous.
I’m not. My statement was (quite obviously, I think) an illustration of the bizarre logic of interpreting “A is better than B” as “people who have difficulties with A should be gatekept from the subject altogether and not use B either”.
That’s still not “a lot more cognitive effort” that you claimed, though, and also not proof that it reduces your appreciation of the animation.
Who cares? That’s such a specific use case, nobody is arguing for or against dubbing with regards to how much you can follow it while high.
Writing this after previously arguing dubbing is better because it allows you to follow the animation more attentively is just ridiculous.
This whole discussion is ridiculous, in fact.